Why Does Petrol Cost More in South Africa Than in Its Neighbors?

Why Does Petrol Cost More in South Africa Than in Its Neighbors?

South Africa is a major fuel supplier to its neighbors—Botswana, Namibia, Lesotho, Eswatini, and others—yet its petrol prices are often higher than in these countries. In October 2024, South Africans paid around R21.05 per litre for 95 octane petrol, while Botswana enjoyed prices as low as R19.00, and Namibia even lower at R18.50. This disparity raises a question: why is petrol cheaper in countries that rely on South Africa for their fuel? The answer lies in taxes, economic policies, and logistics.

South Africa’s petrol price is determined by a mix of global and local factors. The Basic Fuel Price (BFP), tied to international crude oil costs (around $78.54/barrel in October 2024), accounts for 35–53% of the retail price. However, taxes and levies, including the General Fuel Levy (R3.98/litre) and Road Accident Fund levy (R2.18/litre), add up to roughly R6.23/litre—about 30% of the total cost. Additional expenses like transport, storage, and retail margins push prices higher.Despite recent price cuts of R1.14–1.26 per litre, South Africa’s fuel remains pricier than in most neighboring countries. Globally, its prices rank 73rd out of 169 countries, 4.3% below the global average of R23.89/litre (July 2024). However, within the region, South Africa stands out for its high costs.

Botswana, which imports all its petrol from South Africa, offers fuel at ~R19.00/litre. The key difference? Lower taxes. Botswana’s fuel levies are minimal—around 14.64c/litre compared to South Africa’s ~90.6c/litre for 93 octane in 2023. Botswana Oil Limited regulates prices through a streamlined “Unit Rates” system, avoiding hefty levies. Despite its reliance on South African fuel, Botswana’s lower tax burden and efficient distribution keep pump prices down.

Namibia: At ~R18.50/litre, Namibia boasts the region’s lowest prices, thanks to modest taxes (~R3.42/litre, including NAMCOR and MVA levies). Like Botswana, it imports from South Africa but benefits from lighter fiscal policies.Lesotho and Eswatini: Both countries, fully dependent on South African fuel, charge ~R19.00/litre or less. Their low taxes (~20.9c/litre in Lesotho, ~56.3c/litre in Eswatini in 2023) offset transport costs for these landlocked nations.Mozambique and Zimbabwe: These countries face higher prices—R25.36/litre in Mozambique and R32.66/litre in Zimbabwe (2023 data). High taxes, currency volatility, and logistical challenges drive costs above South Africa’s.

- Taxation: South Africa’s high fuel taxes fund government programs, unlike its neighbors, which impose minimal levies to ease consumer burdens. For example, Botswana and Namibia prioritize affordability over revenue generation.

- Economic Context: Wealthier economies like South Africa tend to tax fuel more heavily. Poorer nations like Lesotho and Eswatini keep taxes low to support citizens.

- Logistics and Currency: While landlocked countries face transport costs, these are often offset by lower taxes. Currency fluctuations also play a role—South Africa’s Rand volatility affects its import costs, while neighbors with stable or weaker currencies may face lower relative expenses.

- Subsidies: Unlike oil-producing nations like Nigeria (~R12/litre), South Africa and its neighbors don’t subsidize fuel, but Botswana and Namibia’s low-tax models mimic subsidy effects.

South Africans frequently voice frustration over high fuel prices, especially compared to neighbors. Social media platforms like X highlight sentiments blaming government taxes and inefficiencies. Proposals like the Democratic Alliance’s Fuel Price Deregulation Bill suggest that cutting taxes could lower prices by up to R9/litre, but such reforms face political hurdles. Meanwhile, Botswana is diversifying its fuel sources (e.g., via Mozambique) to reduce reliance on South Africa, potentially stabilizing its prices further.

South Africa’s role as a regional fuel hub doesn’t translate to cheaper petrol for its citizens. High taxes, designed to fund public services, make its fuel pricier than in Botswana, Namibia, Lesotho, and Eswatini, where lower levies prioritize affordability. Mozambique and Zimbabwe, however, face higher costs due to their own economic challenges. As global oil prices and local policies evolve, understanding these differences is key to addressing consumer concerns and fostering regional cooperation.

Follow us Mamelodi News